3 min read

Why the Write editor has fewer buttons than it used to

We removed eleven buttons from the Write editor this spring, including Regenerate. What we learned from watching people write, and what replaced the buttons we took away.

Jun ParkHead of Design

Product
On this page

In March the Write toolbar had nineteen buttons. Today it has eight. The most common reaction from customers has been that the editor feels faster, even though nothing about its speed changed.

This is how we decided what to remove, what we got wrong along the way, and the principle we now apply to every new feature.

How the toolbar grew

Every button had a good reason to exist. Customers asked for Make shorter, so we added it. Then Make longer, More formal, More casual, Simplify, Expand, Rephrase. Each was a shortcut for something you could already ask Pilot to do in words.

By the start of the year the toolbar wrapped onto two lines on a laptop. New users told us they didn’t know where to start. Experienced users had stopped looking at it and typed instructions instead.

What we saw in research

We ran sessions with forty writers across marketing, sales and research teams, watching them work on a real task. Three patterns came up again and again.

  • People typed more than they clicked. Most edits were instructions in plain language: cut the second paragraph, make this sound less like a press release. The tone buttons were used in fewer than 4% of sessions.
  • Regenerate made people passive. When a draft wasn’t right, people pressed Regenerate three or four times hoping for something better, rather than saying what was wrong. The fourth version was rarely better than the first.
  • The useful buttons were hard to find. Check sources and Apply brand voice were the two features most linked to good outcomes, and they were buried among the rest.

What we removed

We removed eleven buttons. Every tone and length shortcut became a suggestion in the instruction box instead: start typing shorter and Pilot offers the options. Nothing was lost; it just moved to where people were already looking.

Regenerate was the hard one. It was the most-clicked button in the product, and removing it felt risky. We replaced it with Revise, which asks a single question: what should change? You can answer in a word, a sentence or by selecting the part that’s wrong.

A button that gives you a different answer is a slot machine. A question about what’s wrong gives you a better one.

In the first month after the change, people revised less often but kept more of what they got. Drafts accepted with only light editing went from 41% to 58%.

What’s left

The toolbar now has eight controls, in the order people use them:

  1. Instruction box
  2. Revise
  3. Check sources
  4. Apply brand voice
  5. Insert from Library
  6. Comments
  7. Version history
  8. Share

Formatting moved to a menu that appears when you select text, which is where every other editor puts it.

What we got wrong

We shipped the first version of the change to 10% of workspaces, and two things went badly.

First, we hid the keyboard shortcuts along with the buttons. Power users who pressed Cmd+Shift+R to regenerate found that nothing happened. We restored every shortcut within a day and made them open the new Revise box.

Second, we didn’t explain the change. A short note in the editor the first time you open it, saying where things went, cut support tickets about the toolbar by three quarters.

The rule we use now

Every proposed button now has to answer one question: would someone who knows what they want type this faster? If yes, it belongs in the instruction box. A button has to earn its place by doing something words can’t, such as showing your sources or your version history.

That rule has said no to more features than it has said yes. We think the editor is better for it. If you haven’t opened Write in a while, take a look and tell us what you’d remove next.

writedesigneditor
Portrait of Jun Park

Written by

Jun Park

Head of Design

Designs the editor, and argues for fewer buttons in every meeting.

All posts
  • Product

    4 min read

    Release 4.2: Autopilot agents

    Autopilot agents now write your recurring reports on a schedule, from the sources you choose, and wait for a person to approve them. Library search is also three times faster.

    Tomás Ferreira and Hector Salinas

  • Guides

    6 min read

    How to check an AI answer in under a minute

    A five-step routine for checking an AI answer before you use it: read the sources, test the numbers, look for the missing side, and know when to stop and ask a person.

    Elise Moreau